Socrates, Aristophanes, and you can Agathon remain trailing revealing catastrophe and you may comedy: “part of the area try one Socrates is actually looking to convince them that same son feeld knows (epistasthai) how exactly to build each other comedy and you may catastrophe, that someone that is by the interest (techne) a tragic poet is a comic poet also” (223d26).
A precise dysfunction, seriously, of speeches created by all the symposiasts who talk past in order to Socrates
Typical poets dont create both funny and you will problem, as they do not make-out of knowledge and hobby (techne) but away from divine determination (Ion 534c56). If they did make-out from interest and you will knowledge, once they was in fact craftsmen poets, they would create both funny and you may catastrophe, since the opposites are always studied by exact same hobby. Therefore the fresh comedic passion in addition to tragic hobby would have to feel one in addition to exact same; just as one and also the same passion, medicine, works together with each other disease and you can health.
At the end of the latest Symposium, Alcibiades has gone away from, allegedly to the throng of Bacchic revelers, exactly who bust towards the his existence due to the fact agents out-of his overtaking like into the acceptance and you may flattery of your crowd
Socrates confides in us exactly what good craftsman poet could develop, he cannot let us know exactly what however create. Most other Platonic spokesmen was significantly more certain. “I ourselves are poets,” the new Athenian Stranger confides in us on Laws, “that have on good our ability written an emergency this is the ideal and also the greatest; anyway, our very own entire constitution was constructed just like the an imitation of the greatest and greatest way of life-the very matter and this we allege ‘s the truest catastrophe” (817b15). Continue reading “The primary terms right here, as we understand regarding Ion, try epistasthai and techne”